Equal 33.33% weight — Lineups.com · Betsperts SG · Winner trends
Tiebreaker: trends score → Augusta SG avg → market odds · Unranked players assigned #11
Tier 1 — Triple-source consensus
Src1: #1Src2: #1Src3: #2
Avg rank: 1.33 · Trends: 17/19
Absolute consensus. #1 or #2 across every source and methodology. The only red flag from Src3: he IS the betting favorite, and 19 of the last 20 winners were not. His overall dominance overrides a single historical pattern.
Src1: #7Src2: #2Src3: #1
Avg rank: 3.33 · Trends: 18/19
The composite's defining finding. Src3 rates him #1 (18/19 — highest in field). Src2 rates him #2. Only Src1 underweights him at #7. Three-source blend makes the strongest possible case he is the best value at ~20/1.
Src1: #8Src2: #4Src3: #4
Avg rank: 5.33 · Trends: 17/19
Consistent top-5 across all three independent methodologies. Form, trends, and the omen narrative all converge. At +2000–2500, the composite's top value play.
Src1: #3Src2: #6Src3: #4
Avg rank: 4.33 · Trends: 17/19
Top-6 across all three sources. Src2's approach-regression concern is counterbalanced by Src1's model and Src3's 17/19 trend score. 'Don't sleep on the Spaniard.'
Tier 2 — Strong three-source contenders
Src1: #5Src2: #10Src3: #3
Avg rank: 6.00 · Trends: 17/19
Src3 is Fleetwood's biggest advocate — 17/19 trends puts him tied 3rd in the field. Src1 loves him at #5. Only Src2 skeptical at #10 (Sunday execution concern). Best finishing-position play in the field.
Src1: #6Src2: #7Src3: #7
Avg rank: 6.67 · Trends: 16/19
Remarkably consistent — 6th, 7th, 7th across all three sources. Serious contender, but the '3 previous Masters starts' pattern and late-collapse tendency prevent top-5 status.
Src1: NRSrc2: #8Src3: #4
Avg rank: 7.67 · Trends: 17/19
Src3 delivers Rose's biggest lift — 17/19 driven by his 2025 runner-up satisfying 'made cut,' 'top-30 finish,' and 'top-6 major' simultaneously. Add his 2026 Torrey win. Best dark horse in the field.
Src1: #10Src2: #3Src3: #10
Avg rank: 7.67 · Trends: 15/19
The wildcard. Src2 rates him #3 on elite Augusta SG data; Src1 and Src3 rate him #10. Back withdrawals fail two trend criteria directly. If healthy: top-3 candidate. As-is: DFS/positional angle.
Tier 3 — Value plays with cross-source support
Src1: #9Src2: #9Src3: #8
Avg rank: 8.67 · Trends: 15/19
The most consistent finding in the entire analysis. Three independent methodologies — stat model, Augusta SG data, historical winner trends — all converge at #8–9. That convergence across completely different lenses is rare and meaningful.
Src1: #2Src2: #5Src3: #9
Avg rank: 5.33 · Trends: 15/19
The composite's most dramatic story. Src1 loved him at #2. Sources 2 and 3 tell a very different story: putter outside top-100 SG on bentgrass (Src2), four direct trend failures including won last year — only 3/61 winners ever repeated (Src3).
Key findings
| Finding | Player | Implication |
| Highest trend score (18/19) | Xander Schauffele | Best value play in field at ~20/1 |
| Most consistent across all 3 | Patrick Reed | #9, #9, #8 — rare convergence |
| Biggest Src3 beneficiary | Tommy Fleetwood | Trends lift him to 5th; best finish-position play |
| Most penalized by Src3 | Rory McIlroy | 4 direct trend failures; data stacked vs. repeat |
| Highest variance pick | Collin Morikawa | #3 or #10 depending on health — DFS angle |
| Composite value play | Cameron Young | Top-5 all sources + Players omen + elite form |
Lineups.com · Stat model + Augusta/course history emphasis · Author bets included
Tier 1 — Clear favorites
World No. 1 · 4 straight top-10s at Augusta · 30 straight top-25 finishes. Model's unanimous top pick. Still elite across every key category: SG T2G, Par-5 scoring, ARG, Prox 200+, and course history.
Defending champion · Best 10-yr SG at Augusta. First-time defenders historically struggle, and a lingering back injury adds mild concern, but game remains top-2.
2023 Masters champion · Top comp course SG. Top-3 in model and comp course history. Proven Augusta winner. Author slightly prefers him as the LIV threat.
Top driving distance · T6, T5 last two Masters. Surging LIV form alongside Rahm. Still chasing first green jacket after leading Sunday in 2025 before fading.
Tier 2 — Strong contenders
Top Majors SG over 5 years · Above avg in all 8 key criteria. The model's stealth pick. Consistent Augusta performer and consistently underpriced.
Runner-up 2024 · Top proximity 200+ · One of 5 above avg in ALL key stats. Elite Augusta debut (T2) and follow-up (T7). Course fit undeniable.
Top-3 Majors SG over 5 years · Multiple top-10s at Augusta · Healthy after rib injury. Recovered from 2025 rib injury with solo 3rd at The Players.
Won The Players 2026 · Both last 2 Masters champions won The Players the same year. The omen-play of the week. Strong Par-5 scoring adds stats.
Tier 3 — Value plays
Most top-12s at Augusta last 8 years · 2018 champion · Best SG: APP season of career in 2026. Freedom of schedule a key intangible.
Top Majors SG over 5 years · Top-30 at Augusta every year last 4 starts. One of only two players (with Scheffler) inside the top-30 at Augusta each of the last four years.
Betsperts Golf — Ryan Noonan · Augusta-specific strokes gained per-round averages · Form-driven analysis
Tier 1 — Clear favorites
Unanimous #1 but Noonan flags a real concern: SG: APP has fallen from 1.25+/round to just 0.08 in 2026. Lost approach strokes in 5 of last 12 rounds. Still the clear favorite.
Only Scheffler gains more T2G per round at Augusta. Six top-10s in last seven Masters starts. Ball-striking fully restored after 2025 rib injury. Noonan's standout elevation vs. the market.
The 'toughest nut to crack.' Elite course history, arguably playing best golf of his career in 2026. The back injury withdrawal from The Players and Valero is the only red flag.
Noonan is very bullish: Young has 'found another level this season.' Three straight ball-striking clinics. Form supersedes course history, and his form is elite. The Players win seals the case.
Tier 2 — Strong contenders
Defending champion · Led field driving distance at The Players. T46 was soft but he gained 1.76 T2G/round. The putter is the legitimate worry on Augusta's bentgrass.
Rahm's approach game is back to 2023 PGA Tour rates after two down years on LIV. Five-event LIV run has been dominant. 'Don't sleep on the Spaniard.'
2.88 avg SG/round at Augusta — 2nd highest in field. Market has cooled after his Players collapse but the Augusta-specific data is hard to argue with.
Runner-up 2025 · Won Torrey Pines 2026. Noonan genuinely impressed by Rose's resurgence. 'I think we should be surprised if he's not in the mix again.' Ceiling play at value odds.
Tier 3 — Value plays
1.92 avg SG/round at Augusta over 5 years is elite. Four top-12 finishes in last five Augusta starts. Considers him positional/DFS rather than outright given price compression.
Results are there but Noonan notes he was never truly in contention in his best finishes here. Plays best vs. strongest fields. Tough to back at 25/1 or shorter.
19-criteria historical winner checklist cross-referenced per player · Higher score = stronger winner pattern match
Score 17–18 / 19 — Strongest trend alignment
Near-perfect profile — 18/19 is the highest score in the field. Only miss: US soil win criterion, a direct casualty of his 2025 rib injury season. Every other box checked, including the critical 'not the betting favorite' trend.
✗ Won on US soil in last 2 yrs — rib injury wiped 2025 season
17/19 but both misses carry real weight. Being the betting favorite has historically been the kiss of death at Augusta — only 1 of the last 20 winners was the pre-tournament favorite. Also missed his pre-Masters tune-up with the Houston withdrawal.
✗ IS the betting favorite · ✗ Did not play 2 wks prior (withdrew Houston)
Src3's biggest surprise — tied 3rd in the field. His TOUR Championship win covers the US soil criterion. T10 at Valero the week before checks the tune-up box. The trends see a well-prepared, in-form, well-ranked player.
✗ Top-6 major finish L2Y · ✗ Top-40 GFG borderline
The missed cut last year technically fails one criterion, and his best major finish of T7 misses the 'top-6' threshold by one spot. Everything else is green. His Players win is the strongest recent qualifier in the entire field.
✗ Missed cut last Masters · ✗ Top-6 major L2Y (best is T7 — one spot outside)
Scores 17/19 with two debatable misses — LIV events simply aren't on US soil, and driving distance data from LIV is harder to validate. His OWGR of #29 barely squeaks the top-30 criterion.
✗ No US-soil win (LIV events in Singapore/South Africa) · ✗ Top-50 DD borderline on LIV data
Rose's 2025 runner-up finish is extraordinarily efficient — it simultaneously satisfies 'made cut,' 'top-30 finish,' and 'top-6 major L2Y' in one result. Add his 2026 Torrey win and he clears 17/19 easily.
✗ Top-40 Par-5 scoring (shorter hitter) · ✗ Top-40 GFG borderline
Score 15–16 / 19 — Solid trend alignment
The '3 previous Masters starts' trend is a meaningful miss — 22 of the last 27 winners had played Augusta at least 3 times before winning. Åberg has only played twice. His 2.88 avg SG/round here is second only to Scheffler.
✗ Only 2 previous Masters starts · ✗ Top-8 last 7 borderline after Players collapse
Reed's DP World Tour wins in 2026 don't satisfy the US soil criterion. He's also an average driver, borderline on the top-50 distance filter. His Augusta-specific resume remains elite regardless.
✗ No US-soil win in last 2 yrs · ✗ Top-50 DD · ✗ Top-8 in last 7 borderline
The trends are genuinely stacked against McIlroy. He fails four criteria with meaningful historical backing — perhaps the clearest cautionary signal in the field.
✗ DID win last year (only 3/61 winners ever repeated) · ✗ IS near-co-favorite · ✗ T46 at Players fails '35th+ last start' · ✗ Missed cut in 2024
Morikawa's back injury directly costs him two trend criteria simultaneously — 'played in one of the two weeks before' and 'finished 35th or better in previous start.' If healthy his profile is elite. The injury is the entire story.
✗ Withdrew from Players + Valero — fails 2 criteria simultaneously · ✗ Below-avg driving distance
Winner
Rory McIlroy
-18 · won by playoff
Tracked players finishing top 10
7 / 10
of predicted pool
Best source this week
Betsperts SG
46 pts · avg 4.5 pos off
Source scoring — this week
Composite
42 pts
avg 5.5 pos off
Lineups.com
42 pts
avg 5.7 pos off
Betsperts SG best this week
46 pts
avg 4.5 pos off
Winner trends
42 pts
avg 5.9 pos off
Points: 10 for winner hit · 7 for top-3 · 5 for top-5 · 3 for top-10 · bonus 2 if predicted rank within 2 of actual finish. Rank accuracy = avg positions off across all tracked players.
Tracked players — predicted vs actual
| Fin. |
Player |
Comp |
Lin |
SG |
Trnd |
Err |
Season source leaderboard
1
Betsperts SG
46 pts
4.5 avg pos off · 1 event
2
Composite
42 pts
5.5 avg pos off · 1 event
3
Lineups.com
42 pts
5.7 avg pos off · 1 event
4
Winner trends
42 pts
5.9 avg pos off · 1 event
Cumulative points across all tournaments this season. Rank accuracy = avg positions off (lower is better).